How Do I Know if My Marketing Is Working? The Numbers I Would Track First

Marketing can produce a lot of numbers without giving you a clear answer. Website sessions, impressions, reach, followers, clicks, open rates, and rankings all tell you something—but they do not automatically tell you whether the business is growing.

If you were asking me whether your marketing is working, I would start with the numbers closest to a customer and work backward from there.

The right marketing metric is the one that helps you make a better business decision—not the one that looks best in a report.

1. Start With the Goal

If the goal is more bookings, track bookings. If the goal is qualified leads, track qualified leads. If the goal is online sales, connect marketing activity to purchases and revenue.

2. Look at Qualified Traffic, Not Just Total Traffic

A spike in traffic is only useful if the visitors match your target customer and engage with the right pages. Look at where traffic came from, what pages people entered on, and what they did next.

3. Track Important Actions

Calls, form submissions, quote requests, purchases, bookings, downloads, and other meaningful actions show whether visitors are moving deeper into the customer journey.

Google Analytics refers to important actions as key events. Your setup should reflect the actions that matter to your business.

4. Measure Lead Quality

Twenty leads that are a poor fit may be less valuable than five leads that closely match your ideal customer. Add a simple way for sales staff to mark leads as qualified, unqualified, won, or lost.

↑ Back to top

5. Know Your Cost per Lead

Divide the marketing cost by the number of qualified leads it generated. This gives you a better comparison across campaigns and channels than looking at clicks alone.

6. Track Lead-to-Customer Conversion

If leads are coming in but few become customers, the issue may be follow-up, pricing, sales process, offer clarity, or lead quality rather than the marketing channel itself.

7. Calculate Customer Acquisition Cost

Look at what you spent to acquire new customers and compare it to average sale, gross profit, repeat purchases, and lifetime value. A channel can be expensive and still make sense if it consistently creates profitable customers.

8. Connect Marketing to Revenue and Profitability

Revenue matters more than surface-level engagement, but profitability matters too. Track discounts, ad spend, labor, fulfillment, and other costs when evaluating whether growth is healthy.

9. Build a Simple Monthly Scorecard

For more on evaluating spend, read How to Spot a Good Marketing Investment From a Bad One.

↑ Back to top

If a number does not help you decide what to keep, fix, stop, or scale, it probably should not be the center of your marketing report.